
Fresh Face – SWOT Analysis
FRESH FACE COLLECTION – SWOT
- Accessible pricing and an inclusive brand mission: e.l.f. positions its products as accessible to a broad range of consumers, which supports its appeal to younger shoppers who may be more price-conscious (e.l.f. Beauty, 2025a).
- Strong retail presence: e.l.f. products are available through major retailers, including Target, Walmart and Ulta Beauty, as well as its own e-commerce channels. This gives consumers several ways to discover and purchase the brand (e.l.f. Beauty, 2025b).
- Established digital and direct-to-consumer presence: e.l.f. was founded as a digitally native brand and operates its own e-commerce site and Beauty Squad loyalty program, giving it opportunities to connect with consumers online and learn from their shopping behavior (e.l.f. Beauty, 2025b).
- A strong position in mass cosmetics: In fiscal year 2025, e.l.f. reported 28% net sales growth and maintained its number-one cosmetics brand position at Target, demonstrating its established presence in the mass beauty market (e.l.f. Beauty, 2025c).
- Commitment to vegan and cruelty-free products: This gives e.l.f. a clear point of distinction among consumers who consider these values when making purchasing decisions (e.l.f. Beauty, 2025a).
- A highly competitive value proposition: Affordable pricing is a strength, but it can also make it harder for e.l.f. to distinguish itself when other mass-market brands compete for consumers looking for lower-priced beauty products.
- Dependence on retail partners: Although e.l.f. has its own online store, a large portion of its sales comes through retailers. In fiscal year 2025, national and international retailers accounted for 83% of net sales, making retail relationships and in-store performance important to the business (e.l.f. Beauty, 2025b).
- A risk of being perceived primarily as a low-cost brand: Its accessible pricing can attract consumers, but it may also make it more difficult to communicate product quality and establish a more emotional connection beyond affordability.
- Maintaining a consistent brand identity: As e.l.f. expands across beauty categories and introduces new collections, it must keep its brand positioning clear and recognizable while appealing to different consumer needs.
- Gen Z’s more occasional approach to makeup: YouGov’s 2024 research found that only 6% of Gen Z respondents wore makeup daily, while 22% wore it occasionally. This creates an opportunity for e.l.f. to speak to consumers who view makeup as a personal choice rather than an everyday requirement (Shah, 2024).
- Interest in products suited to individual needs: YouGov found that 44% of Gen Z respondents considered suitability for their skin type important when choosing makeup. This creates an opening for brands to communicate clearly about product use and help consumers make choices that fit their own routines (Shah, 2024).
- The role of online communities among young adults: Pew Research Center found that 48% of adults ages 18 to 29 are part of an online community. This presents an opportunity for e.l.f. to connect with younger consumers through conversations and shared experiences, rather than relying only on traditional product promotion (McClain, 2026).
- Growing interest in authentic conversations about beauty: Discussions around filters, edited images and appearance standards create an opportunity for beauty brands to address self-image and representation in a more relatable way.
- The continued importance of digital beauty discovery: Social platforms and online communities give consumers spaces to find product recommendations, share experiences and discuss beauty. These behaviors create opportunities for e.l.f. to connect campaign storytelling with product discovery.
- A saturated beauty marketplace: e.l.f. competes with established drugstore, prestige and celebrity-led beauty brands. Consumers have many alternatives, making it difficult to maintain attention and stand out (e.l.f. Beauty, 2025b).
- Changing consumer preferences: Beauty trends can shift quickly and interest in a particular product type or aesthetic may fade. e.l.f. identifies competition and the success of new product introductions as business risks (e.l.f. Beauty, 2025b).
- Economic uncertainty and price sensitivity: Changes in the economy and consumer spending can affect how much shoppers are willing to spend on beauty products, even when brands position themselves as affordable.
- Consumer skepticism toward brand-led social messaging: Audiences may question campaigns about confidence, inclusivity and self-image if the message feels disconnected from the products or the brand’s actual practices.
- Negative experiences with online conversations: While online communities can create connection, they can also expose consumers to criticism, comparison and unrealistic beauty standards. Pew’s research highlights that online connection has both benefits and limitations, which means the campaign’s digital engagement needs to be handled thoughtfully (McClain, 2026).

STRATEGIC INSIGHTS
Make Fresh Face part of a personal routine, not a beauty requirement.
YouGov’s research found that only 6% of Gen Z respondents wore makeup daily, while 22% wore it occasionally. This suggests that the campaign should avoid presenting makeup as something consumers need every day. Instead, Your Skin, Your Story can show Fresh Face as an option for different routines and personal preferences. This responds to the opportunity to connect with younger consumers who see makeup as a choice, while helping e.l.f. distinguish Fresh Face in a competitive market (Shah, 2024).
Success metrics: Fresh Face product-page visits; click-through rate from campaign content to the product page; pre- and post-campaign surveys measuring consideration of Fresh Face.
Use personal stories to make the campaign message feel credible.
The campaign’s focus on self-expression can help e.l.f. connect with consumers beyond product promotion. Pew Research Center found that 48% of adults ages 18-29 belong to an online community, showing the relevance of shared experiences and connection among younger audiences (McClain, 2026). The blog, Instagram posts and newsletter should invite people to reflect, share encouragement and engage with the campaign while keeping Fresh Face visible. This can help address consumer skepticism toward brand-led messaging by making the campaign feel participatory rather than purely promotional.
Success metrics: Social shares, saves, comments and campaign-page visits; number of submitted notes; sentiment of campaign-related comments and mentions.
Connect campaign engagement to clear product information.
e.l.f.’s strong retail and digital presence gives consumers several ways to discover and purchase its products (e.l.f. Beauty, 2025b). However, the campaign’s broader message should not overshadow Fresh Face itself. Product-focused content should explain what the collection is and direct interested consumers to official product information, helping move them from awareness to consideration.
Success metrics: Click-through rate from the blog, Instagram posts and newsletter to Fresh Face product pages; product-page engagement; newsletter opens and clicks; sales or conversion data.
Use the campaign’s inclusive message to strengthen e.l.f.’s brand perception.
e.l.f.’s accessible positioning and established presence in mass cosmetics provide a foundation for a campaign that presents beauty as personal rather than prescriptive (e.l.f. Beauty, 2025a; e.l.f. Beauty, 2025c). Consistent messaging across the blog, social posts and newsletter can reinforce the connection between the brand and self-expression without suggesting that makeup is necessary for confidence.
Success metrics: Pre- and post-campaign surveys measuring brand awareness and associations with accessibility, self-expression and inclusivity; earned media mentions; changes in positive, neutral and negative sentiment toward e.l.f. and Fresh Face.
